Whether to repair or replace windows comes down to three checks: is the frame solid, is the glass still sealed, and does the sash close tight. A sound frame with worn weatherstripping, dried-out caulk or a stiff crank is worth repairing, and the fix is often cheap. A frame that is rotted or warped, a window that lets water into the wall, or single-pane glass that ices up every cold snap is a window to replace. Here’s how to tell which one you have.
Repair or replace your windows: the short answer
- Repair it when the frame is solid and square and the trouble is a part that wears out: weatherstripping, caulk, a crank, a lock or a screen. Manitoba Hydro’s advice is that windows in reasonably good condition are much more economical to repair and seal than to replace (Doors and Windows booklet).
- Replace the glass and keep the window when the only fault is fog between the panes and the frame passes the test below.
- Replace the window when the frame is soft, warped or loose in the wall, when water is getting in, when the sash can’t be made to close tight, or when it’s single-pane glass or bare aluminum that frosts over every cold snap.
- Price both when one window needs three or more repairs.
One thing to know about us first: Arctic Star replaces whole windows. We don’t repair them, and we don’t swap glass only. Where this guide says “repair”, we’re pointing you to a glass shop, a carpenter or your own toolbox, because that is the right answer for a lot of windows. If you’re not sure yet what’s wrong, the 7 signs you need new windows shows how to check.
How long windows last
There is no single number, and age alone doesn’t condemn a window. Two U.S. government planning tables show what building managers expect:
| Window | HUD planning table | U.S. Forest Service table |
|---|---|---|
| Vinyl | 30 years | 20 to 30 years |
| Aluminum | 35 to 40 years | 20 to 30 years |
| Wood (windows that open) | 35 to 45 years | 20 to 50 years |
| The glass alone | Not listed | About 20 years |
Sources: U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development, estimated useful life table for capital planning in apartment buildings (two figures are for family and seniors’ housing); USDA Forest Service, typical life expectancy of building components. Planning figures, not guarantees.
Neither table was written for Manitoba, where a window goes through a temperature swing of about 70 °C between a January night and a hot July afternoon, and every joint, seal and bead of caulk moves with it. What matters more than the total is the order things wear out. Weatherstripping, caulk and hardware go first, and all can be replaced. The sealed glass often goes next, and it can be replaced too. The frame decides the window’s real life: once it rots, warps or comes loose, nothing else is worth fixing.
- Vinyl needs almost no upkeep and doesn’t rot (Manitoba Hydro). On an older vinyl window, look at the glass seal, hardware and weatherstripping first.
- Wood insulates well and can last for decades if it stays painted and dry, but it can warp, twist or rot once water gets in. See vinyl vs wood windows.
- Aluminum frames are tough, but metal conducts heat readily, which makes them less efficient than the others (NRCan). Old aluminum sliders often still slide long after they have become the frostiest windows in the house.
Our own rule of thumb, from our FAQ: start thinking about replacement when windows are 25 years or older, when there’s fog between the panes, or when handles and locks stop working.
Repair or replace: problem by problem
Find your problem in the left column. The middle column assumes the frame is sound, which the next section shows you how to check.
| Problem | Can it be repaired? | Replace the window when… |
|---|---|---|
| Worn or flattened weatherstripping | Yes. A new strip presses or slides into the same groove. Manitoba Hydro rates closed-cell rubber as good and spring metal as excellent for durability, and says felt tape is only good for one season. | The sash is warped or the frame is out of square, so no strip can close the gap. |
| Cracked or missing caulk around the trim | Yes. Seal the inside joints first; outside caulking comes only after that (NRCan). | The gap keeps reopening because the frame is loose, or the wall around it is wet. |
| Stiff crank, loose handle, lock that won’t catch | Usually. Clean and lubricate first. Cranks, latches and locks can be serviced or replaced (NRCan). | Parts are no longer made, or the lock misses because the sash has sagged or warped. |
| Torn screen | Yes, always. | Never for this alone. |
| Fog between the panes | The glass can. Replacing the sealed unit is the best fix, and refurbishing a fogged unit is only temporary (NRCan). Check the warranty first. | The frame fails the test below, or units all over the house are fogging at the same age. |
| Rotted wood in the frame or sill | Only if the rot is limited: dry it, fill it with epoxy filler and repaint (Manitoba Hydro), and stop the water that caused it. | A screwdriver sinks into the sill or a bottom corner, or the rot has come back. |
| Warped sash that won’t close flat | Rarely. A new sash can sometimes be fitted if the frame is still in good condition (NRCan). | Usually. A sash that can’t meet its seal can’t be made airtight. |
| Single-pane glass or bare aluminum frames | You can add a layer. A storm window cuts the heat loss through single glass by almost half (NRCan). | You’re tired of frost, cold rooms and putting up film every fall. |
| Water stains or soft drywall below the window | Maybe. Find the source first: it can be the flashing, the caulk or blocked weep holes rather than the window. | The frame or sill is rotted, or water comes through the window’s own corners. Don’t leave this one for spring. |
Based on Natural Resources Canada’s Keeping the Heat In, chapter 8, and Manitoba Hydro’s Doors and Windows and Sealing, Caulking and Weatherstripping booklets.
For the how-to behind three of these rows, see which weatherstripping fits which window, what fog between the panes means and why windows leak.
The frame test: is this window worth repairing?
Every repair depends on the frame, so test it before you buy parts. It takes about five minutes a window with a flat screwdriver and a strip of paper.
- Look. Check the sill, the bottom corners and the wall just below for stains, peeling paint, mould or swollen trim. NRCan’s inspection list starts with the same things: rot, mould and staining around the window.
- Probe. On a wood window, press the screwdriver tip into the sill and the bottom corners, inside and out, especially where the paint is cracked or peeling. Sound wood pushes back. Rotted wood is soft, and the tip sinks in.
- Check for square. Close the window and look at the gap between the sash and the frame. It should be even all the way round. If you can, measure the frame corner to corner both ways: the two diagonals should match.
- Work it. Open, close and lock the window. It should move without forcing, and locking it should pull the sash snug against its seal. The frame shouldn’t shift in the wall when you push on it.
- Try the paper test. Close and lock the window on a strip of paper. If the paper slides out with no drag, the seal isn’t being squeezed at that spot. Repeat on all four sides.
If it passes every step, the window is a good candidate for repair. If it fails the look or the probe, water has been at work, and the window should be replaced along with whatever has rotted underneath. When we replace a window and find rotten wood under it, we replace that wood at no charge.
A note for Winnipeg: our clay soil moves foundations with the seasons, so a window that sticks for only part of the year may be the wall shifting around it rather than the window wearing out. Check it in another season before you blame the hardware.
The same test decides how a new window can go in. A frame that failed shouldn’t be kept under an insert, where the new window sits inside the old frame: it should come out. See retrofit vs full-frame installation.
What each repair takes, and what it buys you
- Weatherstripping and caulk: low effort, real payoff. Both are do-it-yourself jobs with basic tools, and they fix the most common complaint, which is drafts. What they can’t do is make the glass any warmer: a well-sealed 30-year-old double-pane window is still a 30-year-old double-pane window.
- Hardware: easy, if you can find the part. A crank or a lock is usually held by a few screws. The catch is matching it, so look for a maker’s name on the hardware and take the old part with you.
- A new sealed unit: a trade job and a partial fix. A glass shop measures the unit, has one made and comes back to fit it in your existing sash. You get clear glass and that pane’s insulating value back, and you keep the old frame, seals and hardware. A glass-only swap doesn’t earn the Efficiency Manitoba rebate: the program pays for a complete new window with its own NRCan reference number, and a new glass unit in an old frame isn’t one.
- Rot repair: only as good as the leak fix. Epoxy filler holds in a small, dried-out spot. If water still gets in, the rot carries on behind the patch.
- Storm panels and film: one winter at a time. Shrink film is usually single-use, and the window can’t open while it’s on, so never put it on a bedroom window: bedroom windows must be able to open at all times (Manitoba Hydro).

To decide, list the repairs one window needs. One or two, on a frame that passed the test, is a repair. Three or more, or anything involving the frame, and you should price a replacement before you spend on parts. If the real complaint is your heating bill rather than one bad window, read how to tell if heat loss through your windows is the cause first.
Replace one window or all of them?
You don’t have to do the whole house. Windows of the same age don’t fail at the same rate: the ones that take the most weather and moisture usually go first. Replacing one or a few makes sense when they have failed the frame test and the others pass, or when a leaking window can’t wait for a bigger budget.
Doing them all, or one side of the house at a time, makes sense when:
- they are the same age and failing the same way, so the rest are a few winters behind;
- you want them to match. A new white frame beside 30-year-old ones shows, and new Low-E glass can look a little different from old clear glass;
- the price per window matters. We give a volume discount when you quote the whole house, and most whole-house window jobs take us 1 to 3 days.
The rebate works either way. As of November 2026, Efficiency Manitoba pays $100 for each eligible opening when an ENERGY STAR certified triple-pane window replaces an existing one, and describes the rebate as worth up to $2,000 a home. All our windows qualify. Each opening can get the rebate only once, and each stage needs its own application within 90 days of installation and payment in full. Confirm the current rules with Efficiency Manitoba. Our rebate guide walks through the application. You can also spread the cost with Manitoba Hydro’s loan, which has to be approved before anything is ordered.
If you stage it, start with any window that leaks or has a rotted frame, then the rooms you live and sleep in, then the rest.
What a replacement window costs
To weigh against your repair list, here is what a new window costs installed:
| Window | Small | Medium | Large |
|---|---|---|---|
| Casement | $750 – $1,150 about 24″ × 40″ | $850 – $1,300 about 30″ × 48″ | $950 – $1,450 about 36″ × 56″ |
| Slider | $550 – $800 about 30″ × 17″ | $600 – $900 about 36″ × 22″ | $800 – $1,200 about 48″ × 36″ |
| Single hung | $600 – $900 about 28″ × 36″ | $700 – $1,050 about 32″ × 45″ | $900 – $1,300 about 36″ × 60″ |
Ranges are installed prices before tax and rebates, white frames, based on Arctic Star’s own current quotes — the same numbers as our price calculator. Your exact price comes after a free in-home measure.
That price covers a triple-pane ENERGY STAR window, installation by our own crew with insulation and finishing, removal and disposal of the old window, a lifetime transferable warranty and a lifetime accidental glass breakage warranty. For every style, see window replacement cost in Winnipeg.

Common questions
Is it cheaper to repair or replace windows?
Repairing is almost always cheaper up front, and Manitoba Hydro’s guidance is that windows in reasonably good condition are much more economical to repair and seal than to replace. Replacement becomes the better value when the frame is rotted or warped, or when one window needs several repairs and would still be an old window afterwards.
How long do windows last?
Planning tables used by U.S. government building managers put vinyl windows at 20 to 30 years, aluminum at 20 to 40 and wood at 20 to 50, with the glass at about 20. Real life depends on exposure and upkeep, and the weatherstripping, hardware and glass seal usually wear out before the frame does.
Can you replace just the glass in a window?
Yes, if the frame and sash are sound. A glass shop can replace the sealed unit, which Natural Resources Canada describes as the best fix for condensation inside a sealed unit. It doesn’t qualify for Efficiency Manitoba’s window rebate, and Arctic Star doesn’t do glass-only replacements: we replace whole windows.
Can a rotted window frame be repaired?
Limited rot can. Dry the wood, fill it with epoxy filler and repaint, then fix whatever let the water in. If a screwdriver sinks into the sill or a bottom corner, the frame is past patching and the window should be replaced.
Should I replace all my windows at once?
Only if most of them are failing or you want them to match. Replacing the worst ones first is a reasonable plan. With us, quoting the whole house earns a volume discount, and the work is done in one job instead of several.
Thinking about replacing a window?
If a window failed the frame test, we can measure it and quote a replacement at a free in-home estimate, and explain which products qualify for rebates. Ask us to price just the windows that need it, or the whole house for comparison. Book an estimate online, or get a ballpark first from the price calculator.
Not sure your windows can be saved?
Book your estimate